2014 Annual Science Report

University of Wisconsin Reporting  |  SEP 2013 – DEC 2014

Project 1F: Chemolithotrophic Microbial Communities in Subglacial Sediments

Project Summary

Recent interpretation of Yellowknife Bay, Gale Crater, Mars as an ancient lake basin characterized by low salinity, circumneutral pH, and Fe and S compounds in a range of redox states (1) motivates inquiry into the capability of analogous Earth systems to support microbiomes founded on Fe and S chemolithoautotrophy. The research progress outlined herein was conducted to improve understanding of the microbial metabolisms that promote Fe and S redox transformation in an analogous system – the subglacial environment Robertson Glacier (RG), Peter Loughleed Provincial Park, Alberta, Canada. We seek to better understand the mechanisms by which chemolithoautotrophs access mineral-bound electron donors and acceptors and the potential for biosignature preservation associated with this type of life. Geochemical attributes of the RG subglacial environment that are consistent with the former aqueous habitat at Yellowknife Bay include circumneutral pH, low salinity, and sulfur (S) and iron (Fe) existing in a range of oxidation states. Further, the structure, composition, and function of the endogenous subglacial microbiome at RG is largely shaped by redox transformation of pyrite (FeS2) and chemolithoautotrophic growth on released Fe and/or S intermediates. To achieve these goals we have assembled a collaborative, multidisciplinary team with expertise in molecular biology, microbial physiology, geochemistry, and thermodynamics.

4 Institutions
3 Teams
3 Publications
1 Field Site
Field Sites

Project Progress

Subglacial sulfate production in excess of the oxidative (O2) potential of incoming waters, and in the absence of sulfate bearing minerals, suggests a mechanism for anaerobic pyrite (FeS2) oxidation in circumneutral subglacial systems (1). Ongoing investigations at RG provide new evidence supporting the role of FeS2 -driven chemosynthesis as a mechanism for primary production in cold-dark environments, and a solution to the subglacial sulfate mass balance discrepancy. Novel work builds off findings by Mitchell et al. (2) that reveal microbial communities associated with FeS2 incubated in the RG subglacial outflow are most closely related to those extracted from RG subglacial sediments. Furthermore, the biomass associated with each incubated mineral phase (i.e. pyrite, olivine, quartz, calcite, magnetite and hematite) increases as a function of iron weight percent (2). Together these results suggest FeS2-based chemolithotrophy may play an important role in shaping and fueling the RG subglacial community (Fig. 2). The biogeochemical and geobiochemical mechanisms underlying FeS2-driven chemosynthesis and its influence on aerobic and anaerobic FeS2 oxidation rates under circumneutral pH conditions and near-freezing temperatures remain enigmatic.

Progress to date supplies evidence associating FeS2 oxidation with chemosynthetic primary productivity and carbonate dissolution in subglacial sediments sampled from RG. Quantification and sequencing of ribulose-1,5-bisphosphate carboxylase/oxygenase (RuBisCO) transcripts suggests that populations closely affiliated with Sideroxydans lithoautotrophicus, an iron-sulfide oxidizing autotrophic bacterium, are abundant constituents of microbial communities at RG. Microcosm experiments indicate sulfate production during biological assimilation of radiolabeled bicarbonate. Geochemical analyses of subglacial meltwater indicate that increases in sulfate are associated with increased calcite and dolomite dissolution. Collectively, these data suggest a role for biological FeS2 oxidation in driving primary productivity and mineral dissolution in a subglacial environment and provide the first rate-estimate for bicarbonate assimilation in these ecosystems. Evidence for lithotrophic primary production in this contemporary subglacial environment provides a plausible mechanism to explain how subglacial communities could be sustained in near isolation from the atmosphere during glacial-interglacial cycles (Boyd et al., 2014). This work was published in Applied and Environmental Microbiology by Boyd et al., in 2014.

Efforts were taken to isolate a relevant chemolithoautotroph from RG to further elucidate the biogeochemical and geobiochemical mechanisms of chemosynthetic primary production in the subglacial environment. These efforts yielded an environmentally relevant RG isolate most closely related to the chemolithoautotroph Thiobacillus denitrificans. Isolate growth tested under both aerobic and anaerobic conditions reveal a highly adapted bacterium capable of chemosynthesis through the oxidation of aqueous sulfur intermediates and framboidal FeS2 coupled to O2, NO3- and NO2- reduction at 4 oC.

Abiotic, aerobic FeS2 oxidation at circumneutral pH proceeds through an initial, incomplete oxidation step that produces aqueous thiosulfate (S[~2~O32), a metastable reduced sulfur intermediate. We tested the ability of our RG isolate to grow on aqueous S2O32- in both aerobic and anaerobic medium at 4 oC, conditions relevant to the subglacial system. Growth curves based on geochemical data exhibit the ability of this isolate to couple S2O32- oxidation with O2, and NO3- and NO2- reduction in aerobic and anaerobic systems, respectively. Redox transformations do not occur in parallel abiotic assays, supporting the role of this isolate in driving S2O32- oxidation and thus, sulfate production. Cell count data taken alongside geochemical data confirms the production of new cells under all conditions.

Isolate chemosynthesis was also sustained via oxidation of framboidal FeS2 in circumneutral, aerobic and anaerobic media using O2 and NO3- as oxidants, respectively, at 15 oC. Furthermore these chemosynthetic pathways are capable of enhancing the rate of framboidal FeS2 oxidation relative to abiotic processes. This is most noted in the anaerobic systems where little to no abiotic FeS2 oxidation occurs. Results from this work provide evidence for chemosynthesis-driven anaerobic FeS2 oxidation in the subglacial environment. Geochemically, both anaerobic FeS2 and S2O32- -driven metabolisms exhibited by the RG isolate are capable of satisfying the mass balance discrepancy on sulfate production in the subglacial environment.

Energy requirements for cell production at 4 oC and 15 oC, on aqueous thiosulfate and framboidal FeS2, respectively, will be determined based on cell count data and the thermodynamics of substrate oxidation in aerobic and anaerobic assays. Broad implications include the energetics of cold adapted, FeS2-based chemosynthetic life and its potential role as a primary producer in cold-dark environments. Ongoing work includes evaluating the geobiochemical mechanisms of framboidal FeS2 oxidation under both aerobic and anaerobic conditions. This will be achieved through the use of a semi-permeable membrane to create a physical barrier that prevents cell-mineral contact.

1. M. Tranter et al., Hydrol. Process. 16: 959 (2002).
2. A. C. Mitchell et al., Geol., 41:855 (2013).
3. T.L. Hamilton et al., ISME J, 7: 1402 (2013).

Robertson Glacier, Alberta, Canada, has served as a model environment for improving our understanding of the processes that sustain life beneath glacial ice. Photo by Mark L. Skidmore.

Composition of RG subglacial sediment associated archaeal, bacterial, and eukaryal 16S/18S rRNA genes and transcripts indicates a prevalence of organisms capable of metabolizing Fe and S. Figure adapted from Hamilton et al., 2013

    Eric Boyd
    Project Investigator

    Eric Roden

    Zoe Harrold

    Mark Skidmore

    Objective 4.2
    Production of complex life.

    Objective 5.3
    Biochemical adaptation to extreme environments

    Objective 7.2
    Biosignatures to be sought in nearby planetary systems